Raise the Hammer
By: Ryan McGreal
Published: 2005/08/23 (Category: Energy)
The City of Hamilton is notorious for commissioning studies and then promptly ignoring them (see: Vision 2020). I fear they may be at it again, based on an article in yesterday's Hamilton Spectator (Paul Morse, "City gets help to plan for days of $4 a litre gas", August 22, 2005, Page A8).
Hamilton is taking a unique step in urban planning by commissioning a study into the fallout from a global energy crisis.
But a leading national energy expert says councillors may not like what that report says about the city's bid to create an aerotropolis in Glanbrook.
Richard Gilbert is an authority on "peak oil" -- the point at which global oil production lags behind consumption and begins to decline. The Toronto consultant to the Paris-based International Energy Agency (IEA), warns Hamilton is taking an extreme risk if it expands its urban boundary to include 1,200 hectares of farmland around John C. Munro International Airport.
Air travel in the ways we understand it is doomed," he says. "It's a very dicey business."
We at Raise the Hammer are, of course, consummate professionals and would never stoop to self-aggrandizement or smug vindication, but what the heck: we made essentially the same argument in our July 1 editorial. Jack Santa-Barbara also made a compelling argument in a Spectator op-ed on June 25.
Gilbert draws the obvious conclusion from the fact that air transport is a hundred times less fuel efficient than shipping or rail: "We are going to see the unwinding of the air freight bonanza, entirely because of high fuel prices ... To build an economic development concept on the expansion of air freight is something you seriously have to reconsider."
He also points out that money squandered on an economic hub with poor long-term prospects cannot be spent on "other kinds of development that will put Hamilton in better stead for an energy-constrained future."
Displaying the same pie-in-the-sky optimism that he shared with Raise the Hammer in our recent interview, Mayor Larry DiIanni asks rhetorically, "Do we honestly believe that airplanes will cease to fly through the air?"
Unfortunately for the Mayor's cornucopian ambitions, airplanes are as subject to the laws of physics and chemistry as anything else: without huge quantities of high-energy jet fuel to power them, airplanes will not fly. As petroleum supplies are increasingly constrained, air flight will return to its origins as an expensive toy for wealthy playboys.
There's simply no way wind or solar power is going to keep 380,000 kilograms of steel in the air, no matter how fervently we believe things will stay the same. And yet, the Mayor chastises naysayers for being "so into navel gazing that that we're just not going to open our minds" to airport-based opportunities for the city.
I would argue by contrast that refusing to look at the mounting evidence of an impending global energy crisis is the most dangerous form of "navel gazing" we can indulge in.
The article concludes with a quote from city planner Stephen Robichaud, who points out sensibly that accepting doomsday scenarios leaves no room for planning. Raise the Hammer agrees, but we worry that his alternative consideration, "how will consumers adjust [to more expensive energy costs] and what degree of technological change [will] offset some of their cost," may be a sign that the city is taking the issue seriously, or it might just a smokescreen for more business as usual planning.
NewsfeedsISSN: 1715-1554
Aerotropolis: Will It Fly? - Wednesday, December 3, 2008, at Mount Hope Community Hall, 3027 Homestead Dr., Mount Hope.
City Backs Down on Airport Development Size (Dec. 1, 2008) - Citizens at City Hall (CATCH) reports that the city has backed down on at least one aspect of its dispute with the province on the size of the Airport Economic Growth District (AEGD), a planned in
Same Old 'Traffic Trumps Everything' Thinking (Dec. 1, 2008) -
Apparently, the City Traffic department still doesn't get it.
After turning James and John into two-way streets that slowed traffic down, the city is now looking for ways to speed thing
Toronto Council to Vote on Corporate, Union Donations (Dec. 1, 2008) -
Toronto City Council has another opportunity today to decide whether to allow corporate and union donations to be proffered during municipal campaigns.
City Council has voted against such don
Poor and Dirty (Dec. 1, 2008) -
Your humble editor presents a modest tribute to the Hamilton Spectator report, "Poor and dirty", published November 27, 2008.
Poor and Dirty
They see us rollin'
On the highway
The
Double Downtown Density? We Should be Aiming to Quadruple It (Nov. 28, 2008) - Today's Spectator carries a head-scratching article on a proposal by Councillor Brian McHattie to double the downtown's urban density of 200 people and jobs per hectare to 400 people and j
Councillors Propose Salary Freeze (Nov. 28, 2008) - Councillors Chad Collins, Scott Duvall, Sam Merulla, Bernie Morelli and Terry Whitehead just issued a press release proposing a salary freeze for Councillors and non-union employees across the mun