I fear the worst: a demolition and a reconstruct of something that resembles the Lister only from the outside.
By Tray Shaw
May. 16, 2005
At risk of sounding like someone who can't be pleased, I've been thinking a lot about the proposal from LIUNA to redevelop the revered Lister Block building for offices and retail space.
Everything seems perfect - almost - and maybe that's the problem. I can't put my finger on it, like a newly installed showerhead - its my shower, my regular soap and shampoo, but the water sprays slightly different. It's something that I will have to get used to.
The Lister is beyond repair and the best hope is to rebuild as close as possible to the original. According to LIUNA, if parts can't be salvaged they will be "replicated". Keep in mind that this is referring to the exterior, particulaly the terracotta pilisters, and entablatures, copper spandrels and tapestry brick, embellishments that are absent on any buildings post Art Deco.
The fact that there has been very little mention of the interior is troubling. I believe that despite the closed-door negotiations, everyone has the best interests of Lister and downtown in mind. LIUNA has a great track record with the CN Station, and now will enjoy the benefits of an anchor building at both ends of James Street.
Still, the interior is part of what makes the Lister so special. It's the forerunner of the modern shopping mall, and the L-shaped arcade or 'interior street' makes it architecturally significant. Designed with skylights and a duo-tone marble floor, the arcade/mall connected James to King William. It also features marble baseboards and chestnut wood panelled walls.
I doubt these adornments will be salvaged, and I don't even think LIUNA could find tradepeople skilled in "replicating" terracotta friezes.
The Lister stands out as a Classical Reannaissance style among its contemporaries, which were designed in the Art Deco style during the 1920s. I was recently in Toronto's College Park and the similarities struck me. Both 1920s (College Park is Art Deco), six floors, ground floor retail fronting the street and interior, mixed office and residential above, marble indoor mall, prominent location, grand, beautiful but College Park has been saved and functions very well as a modern use. I hope we can be as proud of Lister as Toronto is of College Park.
College Park, 444 Yonge Street, Toronto (Photo Credit: http://www.torontocollegepark.com/
I was snooping around the Lister when a movie was being shot last weekend and had the chance to step inside. "No pictures please". The first thing that struck me was not what I saw, but what I smelled - rot. Clearly, the building is falling apart.
I had a brief vision, similar to the scene from Titanic when the divers imagined the sheer elegance it once possessed - ladies wearing white elbow-length gloves, knee-length skirts and fancy hats, and gentlemen wearing tweed three-piece suits, with an exposed pocket watch chain and tipping their bowler hat as they say hello - and then my heart sank.
The condition was worse than I thought. I fear the worst, a demolition and a reconstruct of something that resembles the Lister only from the outside. I fear the arcade and elegant interior will be replaced with standard-issue cubicles lit with flourescent lighting and an atmosphere of people who want to get out there.
Artist's rendition of the new Lister Block
The rendering looks impressive and that definitely is our Lister in the drawing. But renderings are often better than the real finished product. AGH was supposed to have a "glittering gold façade;" instead it is dull, yellow siding.
AGH - 'glittering gold' or yellow siding?
The Bank of Montreal was to have an addition that occupied the entire neighbouring parking lot. What will be missing from this rendering?
Bank of Montreal showing proposed addition fronting Main Street.
Although I am skeptical that much will be saved or replicated, I am hopeful. I believe it is a good project and LIUNA will do the best they can. Everyone knows that the Lister has to have something done with it and at this point doing nothing isn't an option. Let's just do the right thing.
The Lister Block will be restored. If there are pieces that cannot be restored, they will be replicated. What you're going to see is the Lister Block restored, with the exception of several buildings adjacent to it. ... You will see a brand-new building with the Lister Block incorporated in it." -- Joe Mancinelli, Vice-President, Labourers' Union of North America (LIUNA)
NewsfeedsISSN: 1715-1554
'Benign Neutrality' is What's Wrong (Jul. 22, 2008) -
Ahhh, things have become a whole lot clearer today after reading a letter to the editor in today's Spectator by John Dolbec of the Hamilton Chamber of Commerce.
The most telling comment i
The City as Dynamic System (Jul. 18, 2008) - I wrote yesterday about the complex and often counterintuitive properties of networks, and the role that simplistic "common sense" thinking can play in leading people to false conclusions about ho
Heat Alert 'Trigger' Too High (Jul. 17, 2008) - Toronto has issued an extreme heat alert - that city's highest warning level to inform and protect vulnerable residents from the dangers of extreme heat. The high humidex is supposed to last u
Passport to Hamilton (Jul. 17, 2008) -
A great new initiative developed by Environment Hamilton and the HSR will be unveiled at a public launch this Friday, July 18th at 10:00 am at Williams Coffee Pub on the waterfront.
Passport
Beyond 'Common Sense': How Traffic Networks Work (Jul. 16, 2008) - With all the talk recently about the Downtown Transportation Master Plan and some councillors' objections to spending money to convert downtown streets to two-way, it seems instructive to stud
Free HSR Fares Not The Way To Go (Jul. 16, 2008) -
Councillor Sam Merulla's recent suggestion that public transit in Hamilton ought to be free would risk making transit an economically and politically unsustainable venture for the city.
T
PRINT EDITION