Special Report: Cycling

Bay Street Bike Lane Installation

The design for the Bay Street bike lanes is a significant improvement over the status quo, but continues to discriminate against over 90 percent of potential cyclists.

By Kevin Love
Published October 23, 2017

Right now, bike lanes are being installed on Bay Street. They will extend from Stuart Street in the North to Aberdeen Avenue in the South.

Sign posted on Markland Avenue
Sign posted on Markland Avenue

The target completion date is October 27, and City workers are taking advantage of our current fine weather to complete the work.

What will these lanes look like?

For the part of Bay Street that for motor vehicles is one-way Northbound, there will be bi-directional bike lanes on the West side of Bay Street. This will feature a contra-flow Southbound bike lane. Signs have already been put up showing this, and much of the pavement for the lane has been painted.

Signs at Bold Street showing contra-flow lane
Signs at Bold Street showing contra-flow lane

View looking South at Bay and Bold Street
View looking South at Bay and Bold Street

The plan for Bay Street is that between Aberdeen and Hunter, it will have bi-directional unprotected bike lanes, as shown in the above photograph. This will be similar to the existing lanes on Hunter Street.

Bay Street North of Hunter will be similar to the existing Cannon Street cycle track. It will have bi-directional bike lanes that are unprotected lanes, but with knockdown sticks and other decorative elements.

These knockdown sticks, flower planters, and so on, are not designed to offer any protection whatsoever, but do provide a visual cue. These have yet to be installed, so no photo is available. At the time this article was written, the bi-directional bike lane has only been installed as far North as Jackson Street.

At Cannon Street, there will be no change to Bay Street's current status of transitioning from a one-way street for motor vehicle operators to a two-way street for motor vehicle operators.

At the same time, the bicycle lanes will also make a major transition. They will transition from bi-directional bike lanes on the West side of Bay Street to two uni-directional bike lanes, one on each side of Bay Street.

This requires people who are riding northbound on Bay Street to shift to the other side of the road at Cannon. As shown in the photograph, bike lanes North of Cannon Street will be unprotected bike lanes.

Unprotected bike lane at Bay and Colbourne
Unprotected bike lane at Bay and Colbourne

The City of Hamilton is currently resurfacing Bay Street between Barton Street and Stuart Street. Unprotected bike lanes will be installed when the resurfacing is finished.

Bay Street being resurfaced between Barton and Stuart
Bay Street being resurfaced between Barton and Stuart

Design problems: Unprotected lanes

Although the new Bay Street installation is a major step forward, there are two major safety issues with the proposed design. The first problem is the unprotected nature of the bike lanes, which exclude 92 percent of the population.

The Portland Model of cycling demographics shows why protected infrastructure is so important.

Four types of transportation cyclists in Portland
Four types of transportation cyclists in Portland

The people who are "Strong & Fearless" are willing to cycle with no infrastructure. The "Enthused & Confident" are willing to cycle on unprotected infrastructure. But the majority of the population is not willing to cycle on unprotected infra. In particular, unprotected infrastructure discriminates against women.

Currently, women only constitute 30 percent of bicycle traffic in the GTHA, with traffic safety being the #1 concern preventing women from cycling.

Unprotected infrastructure also discriminates against seniors, with 90 percent of GTHA cyclists currently being less than 60 years old.

Design solution: Protected Bicycle Lanes

It would be fairly easy to upgrade Bay Street to protected cycle lanes. This would involve using proper traffic safety bollards to protect people from motor vehicle traffic.

Yes, this is more expensive than the "knock-down sticks," which as the name suggests are designed to knock down and provide no protection. However, the City of Hamilton's own Vision Zero web page is showing that the current annual average cost of motor vehicle collisions in Hamilton is $608,000,000 (Yes, $608 million!).

This is the cost of deaths, injuries and property damage due to motor vehicle collisions. That will pay for a lot of prevention.

In The Netherlands, 55 percent of bicycle trips are made by women and adults who are 75 years old or older make one quarter of all their trips by bicycle. This is due to safe, protected infrastructure.

Design problems: Mixing Zones at Intersections

The current proposed design for many of the Bay Street intersections involves a dangerous "mixing zone" where bicycle traffic is proposed to mix with motor vehicle traffic. Needless to say, this is very dangerous.

Where mixing zones have been implemented in the USA, they have resulted in fatal crashes and have been proven to be much less safe than alternatives.

"Mixing zones" also exclude the 92 percent majority of the population. To quote my mother, "At my age, I am not going to play tag with two-tonne lethal weapons." Central Public School is on Bay Street. Yet I venture to predict that not too many parents are going to send their children cycling to school if they have to mix with motor vehicle traffic.

Design solution: Protected Intersections

The safest intersections are where bicycle and motor vehicle traffic are completely separated in time or space. Space separation is achieved by grade separated crossings . Time separation is achieved by simultaneous green traffic signals for cyclists.

Where complete separation in time or space is not possible, we must have protected intersections. Protected intersections have two key features:

  1. Motor vehicle and cyclist traffic is separated until the actual point of crossing.
  2. The crossing is carried out at a 90 degree angle to provide clear sightlines.

Conclusion: A Big Step Forward, But...

The Bay Street bicycle lanes that are currently being installed are a big step forward. Without any infrastructure, only the "Strong & Fearless" were willing to cycle on Bay Street. Over 99 percent of the population was excluded from Bay Street.

The new bicycle lanes will also allow the "Enthused & Confident" to use Bay Street. We will now only be excluding 92 percent of the population, with those excluded being disproportionately women and seniors. So the new situation is over eight times better!

But an even better solution would be proper protected cycling infrastructure that would include and empower the majority of the citizens of Hamilton.

Kevin is a professional accountant and a retired infantry officer with the Canadian Forces. Kevin keeps encountering people who were students of his father, Dr. Robert Love, who was a professor at MacMaster University from 1977-2008. He lives near Durand Park in Hamilton and is currently Vice-Chair of the Hamilton Cycling Committee.


View Comments: Nested | Flat

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to comment.

Events Calendar

There are no upcoming events right now.
Why not post one?

Recent Articles

Article Archives

Blog Archives

Site Tools